Top Auto Insurance Companies

Top Companies

• 

  Shelter

  

  4.1

  • Ranked #1 for customer satisfaction in the Central region by J.D. Power
  • Comprehensive coverage options
  • All policies include roadside assistance and new car replacement
  • Ranked #1 for customer satisfaction in the Central region by J.D. Power
  • Comprehensive coverage options
  • All policies include roadside assistance and new car replacement
  $586

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  State Auto

  

  3.6

  • Customized commercial insurance plans supported by a local agent
  • Protection for rented or leased automobiles
  • Web-based customer portal allows policyholders to update their auto coverage
  • Customized commercial insurance plans supported by a local agent
  • Protection for rented or leased automobiles
  • Web-based customer portal allows policyholders to update their auto coverage
  $1050

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Stillwater

  

  4.0

  • Competitive pricing on bundled policies
  • Offers user-friendly mobile app for policy management
  • Customizable coverage options to fit individual needs
  • Competitive pricing on bundled policies
  • Offers user-friendly mobile app for policy management
  • Customizable coverage options to fit individual needs
  $1150

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Texas Farm Bureau

  

  3.7

  • Ranked third in Texas for overall customer satisfaction in the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Insurance Study
  • Numerous offices throughout Texas
  • Offers rideshare and accidental death benefit coverage options
  • Ranked third in Texas for overall customer satisfaction in the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Insurance Study
  • Numerous offices throughout Texas
  • Offers rideshare and accidental death benefit coverage options
  $1000

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  The Hanover

  

  3.3

  • Distinct endorsements offered that might not be offered by other providers
  • Lower-than-expected volume of private passenger customer complaints, according to the NAIC
  • A variety of auto insurance plans to help balance price and protection
  • Distinct endorsements offered that might not be offered by other providers
  • Lower-than-expected volume of private passenger customer complaints, according to the NAIC
  • A variety of auto insurance plans to help balance price and protection
  $1489

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Turo

  

  3.4

  • All host plans include $750,000 of third-party liability protection provided by Travelers
  • Host plans offer multiple options based on the level of vehicle coverage needed
  • 24/7 roadside assistance is available
  • All host plans include $750,000 of third-party liability protection provided by Travelers
  • Host plans offer multiple options based on the level of vehicle coverage needed
  • 24/7 roadside assistance is available
  $1200

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  United Auto

  

  3.7

  • Provides same-day coverage with proof of insurance and SR-22 filing for eligible applicants
  • Non-owner auto insurance plans offered
  • Multilingual support available in English, Spanish, and Polish
  • Provides same-day coverage with proof of insurance and SR-22 filing for eligible applicants
  • Non-owner auto insurance plans offered
  • Multilingual support available in English, Spanish, and Polish
  $700

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Vermont Mutual

  

  3.0

  • Save by bundling homeowners and auto policies
  • Discounts offered for insuring multiple vehicles and for cars with safety features
  • Local agents ready to help
  • Save by bundling homeowners and auto policies
  • Discounts offered for insuring multiple vehicles and for cars with safety features
  • Local agents ready to help
  $623

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Wawanesa

  

  3.2

  • Highly competitive premium rates
  • Known for excellent customer service
  • Strong financial stability and reliability
  • Highly competitive premium rates
  • Known for excellent customer service
  • Strong financial stability and reliability
  $936

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Westfield

  

  4.0

  • Covers several vehicle types under a single policy
  • Provides options for RV and camper coverage
  • Local agents are accessible
  • Covers several vehicle types under a single policy
  • Provides options for RV and camper coverage
  • Local agents are accessible
  $465

  / year

  Get a Quote

Popular Companies