Affordable Auto Insurance in New York

Top Companies

• 

  Encompass

  

  3.4

  • Various options to tailor coverage
  • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
  • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
  • Various options to tailor coverage
  • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
  • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
  $1155

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Esurance

  

  2.9

  • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
  • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
  • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
  • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
  • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
  • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
  $1032

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Farm Bureau

  

  3.9

  • Certain Farm Bureaus provide telematics programs
  • Most branches offer a variety of discounts
  • Extra membership benefits might be offered, depending on the branch
  • Certain Farm Bureaus provide telematics programs
  • Most branches offer a variety of discounts
  • Extra membership benefits might be offered, depending on the branch
  $554

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Foremost

  

  4.1

  • Various optional coverages offered
  • Possibility of solutions for high-risk drivers
  • Multi-policy savings may apply, including with partner firms
  • Various optional coverages offered
  • Possibility of solutions for high-risk drivers
  • Multi-policy savings may apply, including with partner firms
  $1602

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Freeway

  

  3.8

  • Provides coverage across all 50 states
  • Promotes budget-friendly rates
  • Handles SR-22 filings for high-risk drivers
  • Provides coverage across all 50 states
  • Promotes budget-friendly rates
  • Handles SR-22 filings for high-risk drivers
  $600

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Good2Go

  

  3.7

  • Many more discount options than other high-risk auto insurers
  • Get a quote online
  • SR-22 filing service offered
  • Many more discount options than other high-risk auto insurers
  • Get a quote online
  • SR-22 filing service offered
  $480

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Homesite

  

  3.6

  • Rental car coverage offered
  • Various discounts on auto insurance available
  • 12-month terms possible depending on your state
  • Rental car coverage offered
  • Various discounts on auto insurance available
  • 12-month terms possible depending on your state
  $1050

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  NYCM

  

  3.5

  • Wide range of car insurance discounts offered
  • Optional tiered roadside assistance add-on for car insurance policies
  • Some drivers may qualify for split or single-limit auto insurance coverage
  • Wide range of car insurance discounts offered
  • Optional tiered roadside assistance add-on for car insurance policies
  • Some drivers may qualify for split or single-limit auto insurance coverage
  $952

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Plymouth Rock

  

  3.9

  • Top-rated mobile app
  • Predefined tiered coverage plans with customizable options
  • Access to local agents
  • Top-rated mobile app
  • Predefined tiered coverage plans with customizable options
  • Access to local agents
  $1002

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  PURE

  

  4.1

  • Specialized coverage designed for high-net-worth clients
  • Member Advocates offer extra assistance throughout the claims process
  • Access to local agents
  • Specialized coverage designed for high-net-worth clients
  • Member Advocates offer extra assistance throughout the claims process
  • Access to local agents
  $2500

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Safeco

  

  3.9

  • Multiple optional add-on coverages
  • Claims-Free Cashback program rewards low-risk drivers
  • RightTrack telematics program offered
  • Multiple optional add-on coverages
  • Claims-Free Cashback program rewards low-risk drivers
  • RightTrack telematics program offered
  $629

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  State Auto

  

  3.6

  • Customized commercial insurance plans supported by a local agent
  • Protection for rented or leased automobiles
  • Web-based customer portal allows policyholders to update their auto coverage
  • Customized commercial insurance plans supported by a local agent
  • Protection for rented or leased automobiles
  • Web-based customer portal allows policyholders to update their auto coverage
  $1050

  / year

  Get a Quote

Popular Companies