Affordable Auto Insurance in New York

Top Companies

• 

  State Farm

  

  4.3

  • Many discounts offered in the majority of states
  • Top-rated mobile app for direct policy control
  • Numerous agencies situated nationwide
  • Many discounts offered in the majority of states
  • Top-rated mobile app for direct policy control
  • Numerous agencies situated nationwide
  $918

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  GEICO

  

  4.0

  • Average rates are below the national average
  • Drivers with an at-fault accident may find more competitive average rates than other insurers
  • Rated above average for customer service by J.D. Power in the majority of regions
  • Average rates are below the national average
  • Drivers with an at-fault accident may find more competitive average rates than other insurers
  • Rated above average for customer service by J.D. Power in the majority of regions
  $596

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Progressive

  

  4.4

  • Attractive pricing and numerous discounts for many drivers
  • Extensive options for tailoring policies
  • SR-22 filings at competitive prices for high-risk drivers
  • Attractive pricing and numerous discounts for many drivers
  • Extensive options for tailoring policies
  • SR-22 filings at competitive prices for high-risk drivers
  $742

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Allstate

  

  3.9

  • Various reward programs, like Deductible Rewards and Drivewise, that incentivize safe driving (availability may differ by state)
  • Robust mobile and online tools for convenient claims handling and policy management
  • Teen-focused driver training program available to help lower accident risk
  • Various reward programs, like Deductible Rewards and Drivewise, that incentivize safe driving (availability may differ by state)
  • Robust mobile and online tools for convenient claims handling and policy management
  • Teen-focused driver training program available to help lower accident risk
  $996

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  USAA

  

  4.3

  • Customized coverage designed for military members
  • Exceptional J.D. Power ratings
  • Typical auto insurance premiums below the national average
  • Customized coverage designed for military members
  • Exceptional J.D. Power ratings
  • Typical auto insurance premiums below the national average
  $636

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Liberty Mutual

  

  4.2

  • MexPro offers special coverage for drivers who take their cars into Mexico
  • J.D. Power's 2024 study shows higher-than-average customer satisfaction for auto claims
  • Multiple discounts available to reduce premium costs
  • MexPro offers special coverage for drivers who take their cars into Mexico
  • J.D. Power's 2024 study shows higher-than-average customer satisfaction for auto claims
  • Multiple discounts available to reduce premium costs
  $1200

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Travelers

  

  4.1

  • Comprehensive protection choices
  • A variety of possible savings
  • Nearby agents on hand
  • Comprehensive protection choices
  • A variety of possible savings
  • Nearby agents on hand
  $716

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Nationwide

  

  4.0

  • Comprehensive coverage choices offered
  • Full-coverage rates lower than many competitors
  • J.D. Power–ranked top usage-based insurance
  • Comprehensive coverage choices offered
  • Full-coverage rates lower than many competitors
  • J.D. Power–ranked top usage-based insurance
  $718

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  The Hartford

  

  3.9

  • Strong overall customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power in certain areas
  • Optional coverage add-ons offered
  • Repairs performed at an approved repair facility for a covered claim are guaranteed for the duration of your loan or lease
  • Strong overall customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power in certain areas
  • Optional coverage add-ons offered
  • Repairs performed at an approved repair facility for a covered claim are guaranteed for the duration of your loan or lease
  $1145

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Erie

  

  4.1

  • Outstanding customer satisfaction and claims ratings from J.D. Power
  • Erie Rate Lock can help guard against future premium increases
  • Comprehensive coverage plans come with several endorsements included by default
  • Outstanding customer satisfaction and claims ratings from J.D. Power
  • Erie Rate Lock can help guard against future premium increases
  • Comprehensive coverage plans come with several endorsements included by default
  $745

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Chubb

  

  4.0

  • Masterpiece auto insurance plan permits using original manufacturer parts for vehicle repairs
  • No daily cap on rental reimbursement; total coverage up to $15,000
  • 24/7 customer support team
  • Masterpiece auto insurance plan permits using original manufacturer parts for vehicle repairs
  • No daily cap on rental reimbursement; total coverage up to $15,000
  • 24/7 customer support team
  $974

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Root

  

  3.0

  • Auto insurance premiums are largely determined by current driving behavior
  • Policy management for auto insurance is available via a mobile app
  • In certain states, credit scores may not be considered as a rating factor
  • Auto insurance premiums are largely determined by current driving behavior
  • Policy management for auto insurance is available via a mobile app
  • In certain states, credit scores may not be considered as a rating factor
  $900

  / year

  Get a Quote

Popular Companies