Affordable Auto Insurance in Indiana

Top Companies

• 

  Clearcover

  

  3.0

  • Promotes low prices
  • User-friendly mobile app
  • AI tools could speed up claim payouts
  • Promotes low prices
  • User-friendly mobile app
  • AI tools could speed up claim payouts
  $900

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  American Modern

  

  3.9

  • Insurance plans tailored for collectors and other high-value vehicles
  • Agreed-value total loss settlement offered
  • Online product guide to help customers choose the right policy
  • Insurance plans tailored for collectors and other high-value vehicles
  • Agreed-value total loss settlement offered
  • Online product guide to help customers choose the right policy
  $1400

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Assurance America

  

  3.1

  • Ideal for drivers seeking a local independent agent
  • Part of the profits support community charities in the states where it operates.
  • Mobile app offered
  • Ideal for drivers seeking a local independent agent
  • Part of the profits support community charities in the states where it operates.
  • Mobile app offered
  $700

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Cincinnati

  

  4.1

  • Strong endorsements
  • Ability to include a collector car on primary auto policy
  • RideWell mobile app provides discounts for safe drivers
  • Strong endorsements
  • Ability to include a collector car on primary auto policy
  • RideWell mobile app provides discounts for safe drivers
  $639

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Connect

  

  3.2

  • Comprehensive coverage includes reimbursement for expenses from a stolen key
  • Optional gap and new-car replacement coverage available
  • Underwritten by American Family, which ranked above average in J.D. Power's U.S. Insurance Digital Experience Study for shopping and service
  • Comprehensive coverage includes reimbursement for expenses from a stolen key
  • Optional gap and new-car replacement coverage available
  • Underwritten by American Family, which ranked above average in J.D. Power's U.S. Insurance Digital Experience Study for shopping and service
  $1000

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Costco

  

  3.8

  • Costco members might prefer buying their insurance where they do their regular shopping
  • Gap coverage is available
  • Claims representatives are on call 24/7
  • Costco members might prefer buying their insurance where they do their regular shopping
  • Gap coverage is available
  • Claims representatives are on call 24/7
  $1000

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Country Financial

  

  4.2

  • Distinct coverage options and savings
  • Top-rated customer satisfaction by J.D. Power
  • Compatible with local agents
  • Distinct coverage options and savings
  • Top-rated customer satisfaction by J.D. Power
  • Compatible with local agents
  $975

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Electric

  

  3.1

  • Comprehensive coverage plans offer optional add-ons not commonly available elsewhere
  • The Risk Coach program assists in spotting coverage gaps
  • A wide range of discounts could help you reduce costs
  • Comprehensive coverage plans offer optional add-ons not commonly available elsewhere
  • The Risk Coach program assists in spotting coverage gaps
  • A wide range of discounts could help you reduce costs
  $552

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Elephant

  

  4.0

  • Promotes a variety of possible discount options
  • Permits combining Elephant auto insurance with certain non-Elephant insurance products
  • Provides a few uncommon auto insurance add-on options
  • Promotes a variety of possible discount options
  • Permits combining Elephant auto insurance with certain non-Elephant insurance products
  • Provides a few uncommon auto insurance add-on options
  $650

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Encompass

  

  3.4

  • Various options to tailor coverage
  • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
  • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
  • Various options to tailor coverage
  • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
  • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
  $1155

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Esurance

  

  2.9

  • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
  • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
  • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
  • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
  • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
  • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
  $1032

  / year

  Get a Quote
• 

  Falcon

  

  3.0

  • May provide policies to individuals unable to obtain coverage elsewhere, including SR-22 submissions
  • Mobile app receives high ratings
  • Over 1,200 agents available at physical offices for customers who prefer in-person service
  • May provide policies to individuals unable to obtain coverage elsewhere, including SR-22 submissions
  • Mobile app receives high ratings
  • Over 1,200 agents available at physical offices for customers who prefer in-person service
  $1000

  / year

  Get a Quote

Popular Companies