Affordable Auto Insurance in Pennsylvania

Top Companies

  • Cincinnati Insurance
    Cincinnati
    Rating
    4.1
    • Strong endorsements
    • Ability to include a collector car on primary auto policy
    • RideWell mobile app provides discounts for safe drivers
    • Strong endorsements
    • Ability to include a collector car on primary auto policy
    • RideWell mobile app provides discounts for safe drivers
    $639
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Connect Insurance
    Connect
    Rating
    3.2
    • Comprehensive coverage includes reimbursement for expenses from a stolen key
    • Optional gap and new-car replacement coverage available
    • Underwritten by American Family, which ranked above average in J.D. Power's U.S. Insurance Digital Experience Study for shopping and service
    • Comprehensive coverage includes reimbursement for expenses from a stolen key
    • Optional gap and new-car replacement coverage available
    • Underwritten by American Family, which ranked above average in J.D. Power's U.S. Insurance Digital Experience Study for shopping and service
    $1000
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Costco Insurance
    Costco
    Rating
    3.8
    • Costco members might prefer buying their insurance where they do their regular shopping
    • Gap coverage is available
    • Claims representatives are on call 24/7
    • Costco members might prefer buying their insurance where they do their regular shopping
    • Gap coverage is available
    • Claims representatives are on call 24/7
    $1000
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Cure Insurance
    Cure
    Rating
    4.0
    • Credit, job and education not considered for pricing
    • All auto policies include basic roadside assistance
    • Payments and claims can be handled online
    • Credit, job and education not considered for pricing
    • All auto policies include basic roadside assistance
    • Payments and claims can be handled online
    $900
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Electric Insurance
    Electric
    Rating
    3.1
    • Comprehensive coverage plans offer optional add-ons not commonly available elsewhere
    • The Risk Coach program assists in spotting coverage gaps
    • A wide range of discounts could help you reduce costs
    • Comprehensive coverage plans offer optional add-ons not commonly available elsewhere
    • The Risk Coach program assists in spotting coverage gaps
    • A wide range of discounts could help you reduce costs
    $552
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Encompass Insurance
    Encompass
    Rating
    3.4
    • Various options to tailor coverage
    • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
    • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
    • Various options to tailor coverage
    • EncompassOne policy expands optional protections
    • 24/7 roadside assistance app offered
    $1155
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Esurance Insurance
    Esurance
    Rating
    2.9
    • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
    • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
    • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
    • Top-rated mobile app for managing policies
    • Simple online quotes and fast coverage purchase
    • Supported by Allstate, a top-rated insurer
    $1032
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Farm Bureau Insurance
    Farm Bureau
    Rating
    3.9
    • Certain Farm Bureaus provide telematics programs
    • Most branches offer a variety of discounts
    • Extra membership benefits might be offered, depending on the branch
    • Certain Farm Bureaus provide telematics programs
    • Most branches offer a variety of discounts
    • Extra membership benefits might be offered, depending on the branch
    $554
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Foremost Insurance
    Foremost
    Rating
    4.1
    • Various optional coverages offered
    • Possibility of solutions for high-risk drivers
    • Multi-policy savings may apply, including with partner firms
    • Various optional coverages offered
    • Possibility of solutions for high-risk drivers
    • Multi-policy savings may apply, including with partner firms
    $1602
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Freeway Insurance
    Freeway
    Rating
    3.8
    • Provides coverage across all 50 states
    • Promotes budget-friendly rates
    • Handles SR-22 filings for high-risk drivers
    • Provides coverage across all 50 states
    • Promotes budget-friendly rates
    • Handles SR-22 filings for high-risk drivers
    $600
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Good2Go Insurance
    Good2Go
    Rating
    3.7
    • Many more discount options than other high-risk auto insurers
    • Get a quote online
    • SR-22 filing service offered
    • Many more discount options than other high-risk auto insurers
    • Get a quote online
    • SR-22 filing service offered
    $480
    / year
    Get a Quote
  • Grange Insurance
    Grange
    Rating
    3.7
    • Extensive range of coverage choices
    • Multiple discount opportunities
    • Local agents on hand
    • Extensive range of coverage choices
    • Multiple discount opportunities
    • Local agents on hand
    $843
    / year
    Get a Quote

Popular Companies

  • State Farm Insurance
  • GEICO Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Allstate Insurance
  • USAA Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Farmers Insurance
  • Travelers Insurance